Debate-who would win

Dwarves

My first instinct would be Elves... but thinking about it, probably dwarves. They have good strong armour and weapons, good military tactics and are a smaller target for the elven archers 🤣 Plus they have double the amount of people in this scenario. Seems to difficult for Elves to overcome

I'm thinking Dwarves, too. Numbers matter. It also depends on the human...are these Dúnedain? If so, then humans.

Could have a huge answer for this as there are many different things that could happen but I won't haha. I'm going for dwarves too.

It looks like my opinion will be unpopular, but I'm going to go with the elves, especially if they're Noldor at the height of their power.

No matter who wins, the orcs will be taken out first because everyone else will gang up against them.

I think the Elves. Especially elves from the first or second age. Just curious why are there not the same numbers for all

Not the same numbers as eleves would win hands down on speed and accuracy of arrows alone if the numbers were the same.

I agree for dwarves, also don't dwarves have really good strength and can keep going for hours? I think it was mentioned somewhere in the hobbit or lotr.

I think it depends on the time frame but i think the elves stand a good chance however if it is 3000 men from the first age then i might put my money on them

I think a fairer contest would be 1500 dwarves and 1000 elves. If there are things to climb on, elves win. If not, dwarves would probably win.